Wrenn and Six
Modern Horizons · #217 · BGS Standard tier
| Comp price | $240 |
| Less raw cost | −$23 |
| Less BGS Standard fee | −$50 |
| Less return shipping | −$10 |
| Less eBay fee (13.25% + $0.30) | −$32 |
| NET | +$125 |
| ROI | +557% |
| Comp price | $130 |
| Less raw cost | −$23 |
| Less BGS Standard fee | −$50 |
| Less return shipping | −$10 |
| Less eBay fee (13.25% + $0.30) | −$18 |
| NET | +$30 |
| ROI | +133% |
| Comp price | $75 |
| Less raw cost | −$23 |
| Less BGS Standard fee | −$50 |
| Less return shipping | −$10 |
| Less eBay fee (13.25% + $0.30) | −$10 |
| NET | −$18 |
| ROI | −79% |
Compare graders
Same card, other graders. Each link opens that grader's full breakdown.
Pop velocity
Analysis
Wrenn and Six sits in Modern Horizons, part of the Single-Set Era era on Cardboard Assets. Raw spot is $22.52 per the most recent PriceCharting loose comp, last refreshed May 4, 2026.
I'm scoring this a 76/100 — PLAY. The math: $125 expected value at BGS Standard tier, less raw cost $23, less $50 grading fee, less $10 return shipping, less $17 eBay fee = +$26 net per copy. ROI works out to 116% on the raw cost basis.
BGS Standard tier turnaround runs about 20 days. Annualized for capital velocity, that's roughly +2109% APR — useful framing if you're thinking about this as a capital allocation, not a one-shot trade.
Pop is growing modestly — +13% Grade 10s in the last 30 days. Not a saturation alarm, but worth tracking. Honestly, the call gets clearer with another month of pop data.
Sourcing raw: this is a sub-$100 card, so eBay BIN under your raw target ($22.52) is the play. Look for "Near Mint" listings with sharp corners and centered art. Skip anything described as "Played" or "Light Play" unless the price is below the below-9 comp of $75.
Risk to size: grading is one-way. Grading fees aren't refundable, the round-trip eats 20 days of capital, and the comp data lags real-time market shifts. Numbers above pull from PSA POP Report, recent eBay sold listings, and PriceCharting comps as of 2026-05-04.
Methodology · Back to all plays · Affiliate links carry FTC-required disclosure. We may earn a commission when you buy through these links — never alters our analysis or scoring.